 |
| The Morgan Library & Museum |
Dear Bookclub,
Marie Benedict & Victoria Christopher Murray's "The Personal Librarian" spanned the readers' ideal realm, offering fact, fiction and fantasy. The trifecta for a balanced bookclub proved to satisfy our group's discussion.
 |
| Bella de Costa Greene by Clarence White, 1911 |
From Lynne:
We had a good turnout with seven members attending.
We enjoyed a beautiful Fall evening on the patio and filled up on Chicken Kabobs, Rice and Greek Salad as we discussed The Personal Librarian.
Overall most enjoyed the book but were conflicted on Belle’s choice to live a life as a white woman. Would she have achieved what she did if her race was revealed? Would JP Morgan have hired her? Was Belle’s decision to hide her identity contradictory to her father’s fight for Civil Rights and equality for all? Many questions…
It was generally agreed that Belle made the right choice given the times and the discrimanation that African American women then faced. Belle not only protected her family in that regard but provided for them financially as well. That would not have been possible without her having hidden her identity. We were all impressed with how Belle navigated the world of art and antiquities with her intellect and savvy. A world and profession dominated by men who’s respect she earned.
We discussed that in a way Belle did champion the equality her father fought for by orchastraing the change in status of the Pierpont Morgan Library from private collection to a public institution. “Yes, it’s been described as the most meaningful cultural gift in American History.”
Several of us thought a Bookclub excursion to NYC and visit to the Pierpont Morgan Library would be wonderful!!!!
Unable to attend, and grateful to Lynne for her reporting, I wondered about the writers' process. As I read, I sensed distinct styles, oscillating between chapters yet there is no evidence that this was intended. The authors have shared on many forums about their experience writing together, sharing work through the pandemic, the black and white perspectives, historical fiction vs. contemporaries, researching and editing.... all fascinating and a stand alone story itself. Please enjoy this interview with the authors:
https://www.themorgan.org/about/introduction
Yes, let's go! Reminiscent of our Huntington Library visit, I know we would love it.
Lynne's suggestions for an upcoming read:
"Our Missing Hearts" Celeste Ng
"Solita" Javier Zamora* chosen
"Memphis" Tara M. Stringfellow
Up next:
LK
No comments:
Post a Comment